Mathematical Self-Efficacy and Enactive-Iconic-Symbolic Representations: A Narrative Systematic Review of Elementary School Students

Authors

  • Ofir Nokas Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia
  • Tina Hayati Dahlan Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia
  • Idat Muqodas Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia
  • Mubiar Agustin Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26740/jimes.v4n2.p119-141

Keywords:

Bandura's sources of self-efficacy, concrete-pictorial-abstract approach, enactive-iconic-symbolic representations, mathematical self-efficacy, narrative systematic review

Abstract

Mathematical self-efficacy is a well-established predictor of mathematics achievement in elementary education; yet the psychological mechanisms through which representational instruction, specifically Bruner's enactive-iconic-symbolic (EIS) framework, shapes students' self-efficacy beliefs have never been explicitly integrated or synthesized. This narrative systematic review aimed to (1) identify empirical evidence on the relationship between EIS representational stages and elementary students' mathematical self-efficacy, and (2) map the proposed differential contribution of each EIS stage to Bandura's four sources of self-efficacy: mastery experience, vicarious experience, verbal persuasion, and physiological-affective states. A systematic search was conducted in Scopus (February 27, 2026), supplemented by manual searches in Google Scholar, ERIC, and PubMed. Of 482 screened records, 10 studies comprising 3,653 students from six countries met the inclusion criteria, yielding seven effective independent evidence units. Study quality was assessed using an adapted Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) 2018. The protocol followed PRISMA 2020 guidelines. The concrete-pictorial-abstract (CPA) approach consistently enhanced mathematical self-efficacy across intervention contexts, with the greatest benefits observed for low-ability students (η² = .16, large effect). A hypothesized differential pattern was derived through narrative synthesis: the enactive stage is proposed to predominantly activate physiological-affective states through anxiety reduction, the iconic stage to facilitate vicarious experience through visual modeling, and the symbolic stage to strengthen verbal persuasion through ability-attributional feedback, while mastery experience predominated across all three stages. Crucially, this mapping is inferential, no study directly measured stage-specific self-efficacy changes and should be treated as a testable hypothesis. The EIS-Bandura propositional framework offers a theoretically testable foundation for designing elementary mathematics curricula that explicitly scaffold both cognitive and self-efficacy development. However, due to critical methodological limitations, a single-database search (Scopus only), an Open Access filter, and the entirely inferential nature of the stage-specific mapping, this framework should be considered a hypothesis-generating synthesis rather than a definitive evidence base. Longitudinal research directly measuring self-efficacy at each EIS stage transition is urgently needed to empirically validate the proposed mapping.

Published

2026-11-13

How to Cite

Nokas, O., Dahlan, T. H., Muqodas, I., & Agustin, M. (2026). Mathematical Self-Efficacy and Enactive-Iconic-Symbolic Representations: A Narrative Systematic Review of Elementary School Students. Journal of the Indonesian Mathematics Education Society, 4(2), 119–141. https://doi.org/10.26740/jimes.v4n2.p119-141
Abstract views: 19