Peer Review Process
Peer Review Process
Every manuscript submitted to JDCMS undergoes double-blind peer review: reviewers do not know the authors' identities, and authors do not know the reviewers' identities. Each manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the relevant field.
The review process follows these stages:
- Submission. Authors submit the manuscript through the OJS system after registering as an author. Manuscripts sent by email are not processed.
- Initial screening (desk review). The editor checks the manuscript's fit with the Focus and Scope, compliance with the Author Guidelines and template, and similarity level. This stage takes approximately 1–2 weeks. Manuscripts that fail this stage are returned to the authors or declined.
- Peer review. Manuscripts that pass screening are sent to at least two reviewers. Reviewers assess originality, contribution to knowledge, methodological rigor, clarity of argument, quality of visual material, and relevance of references. Reviewers are given 3–4 weeks to complete the review.
- Editorial decision. Based on the reviewers' reports, the editor issues one of the following decisions: Accept Submission, Revisions Required (minor revision), Resubmit for Review (major revision), or Decline Submission.
- Revision. Authors revise the manuscript and submit a response letter explaining how each comment has been addressed. Revisions must be returned within 2–4 weeks; late revisions may be treated as a new submission.
- Final decision. The editor-in-chief makes the final decision on acceptance, considering the reviewers' recommendations and the revised manuscript. Where reviewers disagree, a third reviewer may be invited.
- Copyediting, layout and proofreading. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited and laid out according to the JDCMS template. Authors receive the galley proof for final checking, to be returned within 3–5 days.
- Publication. The article is assigned a DOI and published in the next available issue.
The entire process from submission to the first decision takes approximately 8–12 weeks. The editorial board guarantees that reviewers have no conflict of interest with the authors and that all manuscripts are treated as confidential documents.