Legal Philosophy’s Role in Human Rights and Fiscal Governance: Indonesia and the Philippines Comparative Insights
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26740/jsh.v7n2.p437-462Abstract
This article addresses the critical gap in the insufficient integration of legal-philosophical principles—such as justice, equity, and the rule of law—into local fiscal policy frameworks. This research adopts a normative-juridical method with a comparative and conceptual approach. Data were analyzed through classical and contemporary legal-philosophical perspectives to evaluate the extent to which legal norms are either upheld or neglected in budgeting processes and fiscal governance. The findings reveal that Indonesia’s legal framework emphasizes decentralization and participatory budgeting but lacks mechanisms to ensure rights-based fiscal priorities. Conversely, the Philippines exhibits stronger civil society engagement in local fiscal issues but faces challenges of legal fragmentation and weak enforcement. Both countries demonstrate a limited philosophical foundation in fiscal policymaking, which undermines the realization of social and economic rights.This study concludes that embedding legal philosophy into local fiscal governance is essential for advancing the substantive fulfillment of human rights. The article recommends the institutionalization of rights-based budgeting principles, enhanced legal education for local officials, and stronger normative alignment between decentralization laws and human rights obligations.
References
A bdollah Bahmanpouri, Ali Hosseini. 2024. “Comparative Analysis of Natural Law and Natural Rights from the Point of View of the Intellectual Philosophy of Locke and Kant.” Journal of Legal Philosophy Studies 1(1):139–60.
Acharya, Keshav Kumar and Habib Zafarullah. 2024. “Whither Demarginalization, Inclusion and Effectiveness? Challenges of Local Government Planning in Nepal.” Millennial Asia 15(2):216–35.
Adeoye, Moses Adeleke. 2025. “Kant’s Legacy: Exploring Borders, Races, and Gender in His Philosophy.” Jurnal Theologia 36(1):13–34.
Adrison, Vid. 2024. “Fiscal Sustainability in Indonesia: Policies and Progress.” Asian Economic Policy Review 19(2):224–47.
Alamsyahbana, Muhammad Isa and Rachmad Chartady. 2025. “Implementation of SDG 14 and Blue Economy Policies in Southeast Asia: A Comparative Policy Review.” Jurnal Ilmiah Akuntansi Kesatuan 13(3):603–16.
de Almeida, Miguel Régio. 2025. “The Limits of Legal Imagination: Revising Philosophy of Human Rights’ Foundational Events and Myths.” Pp. 311–21 in Exploring the Boundaries of Law. Living Signs of Law.
Bisoyi, Akanksha. 2025. “The Rule of Law Philosophy and Design Standards.” Pp. 55–91 in Blockchain and Legitimacy. Law, Governance and Technology Series.
Challoumis, Constantinos. 2025. “Economocracy: Global Economic Governance.” Economies 13(8):230.
Chidi Paul Orji, Rufus Godswill Nwagbara, Tijani Taiwo Egberongbe, Peter Damian Ezechi Chukwu. 2025. “A Critique of John Rawls Ethical Principle of Justice and the Problems of Social Justice in Modern Society.” NIU Journal of Legal Studies 11(1):73–80.
Cruz Manzano, Soleil Erika. 2025. “Versions of Transformation: Insights On Good Local Governance In Low-Income Cities In The Philippines.” Policy & Governance Review 9(2):142.
Dadashpoor, Hashem, Ailin Sheydayi, and Mohsen Esmaeili. 2025. “Perspectives on the Public Interest and Social Justice in Planning.” Journal of Planning Education and Research 45(3):578–91.
Dicky Eko Prasetio, Muh. Ali Masnun, Arinto Nugroho, Denial Ikram, Noviyanti. 2024. “Discrimination Related to Labour Age Limitation in Indonesia : A Human Rights and Comparative Law Perspective.” Suara Hukum 6(2):228–54.
Dicky Eko Prasetio, Muh Ali Masnun, Bayangsari Wedhatami. 2024. “Legal Uncertainty of Golf Game as Sports and Entertainment Branch in Local Tax Imposition.” Wawasan Yuridika 4(1):76–93.
Dicky Eko Prasetio, Muh Ali Masnun, Hananto Widodo. 2024. “The Politics of Naturalization Law for Sports Interests: An Orientation to Realize National Inclusivity.” Pp. 1067–74 in Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Social Sciences and Law (ICSSL 2024).
Disantara, Fradhana Putra, Ruetaitip Chansrakaeo, Mohamad Jazuli, Ni Putu Ratnayutika, Rini Triastutiek, and Claudya Inamas Putri Umiasih. 2022. “The Enigma of Ethics: Code of Ethics Enforcement on Covid-19 Health Protocol.” DE LEGA LATA: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum 7(1):1–21.
Ferry, Laurence and Thomas Ahrens. 2025. “‘A Practice of Fairness’: Social Equity Budgeting in Freedom City.” Public Administration 1(1):4–7.
Ghafoor, Abdul, Zahoor Khan, and Rahat Shabbir. 2023. “The Role of Local Government in Community Development in Pakistan.” Global Sociological Review VIII(I):240–50.
Ghulam Yahya Khan, Muhammad Ehsan, Shams un Nisa Abbasi, Sumera Javaid, Shah-E-Yar Qadeem, and Dr. Shams Ur Rahman. 2025. “The Role of Fiscal Decentralization in Promoting Regional Economic Convergence.” Social Science Review Archives 3(1):2046–56.
Hadpakdee, Aphinop. 2025. “Decentralization and Democratic Governance: A Comparative Study of Local Government Reforms in Southeast Asia.” Journal of Modern Academic Social Science 1(2):38–52.
Hamaish Khan, Syeda Saima Shabbir, Atta Ul Mustafa, Omer Shabbir, and Sumaira Jabbar Sheikh. 2025. “Constitutional Rights and Access to Justice in Pakistan: A Comprehensive Analysis with Case Laws.” Social Science Review Archives 3(1):2080–98.
Hamzani, Achmad Irwan, Tiyas Vika Widyastuti, Nur Khasanah, and Mohd Hazmi Mohd Rusli. 2023. “Legal Research Method: Theoretical and Implementative Review.” International Journal of Membrane Science and Technology 10(2):3610–19.
Harianto, Jakoep Ezra. 2025. “The Relevance of Philosophy in Shaping Contemporary Social Ethics.” International Journal for Science Review 2(1):1–9.
Hemel, Daniel. 2025. “Formalism, Functionalism, and Nonfunctionalism in the Constitutional Law of Tax.” The Supreme Court Review 2024(1):327–63.
Hidayat, Rahmad. 2024. “Power Networks of Political Families in Southeast Asia: The Enduring Dynastic Influence in Democratic Contexts.” JAS (Journal of ASEAN Studies) 12(2):413–38.
Huarcaya, Valeria and Rafael Quispe. 2024. “Socioeconomic Inequality and Access To Justice: A Comparative Analysis Of Legal Aid Systems.” International Journal of Sociology and Law 1(1).
Ibric, Samra. 2023. “Ronald Dworkin: Seeking Truth and Justice through Responsibility.” Laws 12(3):41.
Ibrohim, Ibrohim and Ismanudin Ismanudin. 2025. “Performance of Regional Development Planning Policy Through Development Plan Deliberation (Musrenbang) in the Framework of Optimizing Regional Autonomy.” Gema Wiralodra 16(1):22–34.
Lin, Shuyang. 2024. “A Synthesis of Kantian Ethics and Rousseauvian General Will in Justifying the Moral Ground of Political Laws.” Humanities and Social Sciences Communications 11(1):593.
Madonsela, Thuli N. 2025. “Mainstreaming Social Justice in Fiscal Policy Design: A Socio-Legal Case for an Income Support Grant.” Modern Economy 16(04):681–703.
Mao, Lan. 2025. “Fiscal Vertical Imbalance and Income Inequality: A Threshold Effect Analysis Based on Government Expenditure” edited by A. Faturohim. PLOS ONE 20(1):e0317537.
Martinez de Campos, Mónica. 2025. “Challenges of Health and Ageing in Portugal’s Population: Promote Dignity and Non-Discrimination.” Oñati Socio-Legal Series 1(1):1–4.
Maryanti, S., Harahap, T. ., Murni, Y. 2025. “Effectiveness of Regional Expenditure Budget Management in Riau Province: Analysis and Recommendations.” ADPEBI International Journal of Business and Social Science 5(1).
Prasetio, Dicky Eko, Muh. Ali Masnun, Fradhana Putra Disantara, and Noviyanti Noviyanti. 2025. “The Construction Of The Lex Sportiva Principle In Indonesia’s Sports Law: Implications And Future Arrangements.” UUM Journal of Legal Studies 16(2):58–69.
Prasetio, Dicky Eko, Muh. Ali Masnun, and Noviyanti Noviyanti. 2025. “Post-Election Reconciliation in 2024 as a Constitutional Convention in Indonesia: A Progressive Legal Culture Perspective.” Jambura Law Review 7(1):176–96.
Prasetio, Dicky Eko, Muh. Ali Masnun, and Hananto Widodo. 2025. “Affirmative Action for Persons with Disabilities to Ensure the Right to Be Elected in General Elections.” Nusantara Science and Technology Proceedings 1(1):205–10.
Roberts-Cady, Sarah. 2025. “Rawls and Economic Liberties.” Res Publica 31(1):25–45.
Rohman, Moh. Mujibur, Nashrul Mu’minin, Mowafg Masuwd, and Elihami Elihami. 2024. “Methodological Reasoning Finds Law Using Normative Studies (Theory, Approach and Analysis of Legal Materials).” Maqasidi: Jurnal Syariah Dan Hukum 4(2):204–21.
Rosyidin, Mohamad and Indra Kusumawardhana. 2025. “Major Power Wannabe : Military Modernization, Status Signaling, and Indonesia’s Foreign Policy under Yudhoyono and Widodo.” Journal of Global Security Studies 10(4).
Rotar, Laura Južnik. 2025. “Fiscal Sustainability and Economic Growth in the Light of New Economic Governance.” Technological and Economic Development of Economy 31(3):663–84.
Schugurensky, Daniel and Laurie Mook. 2024. “Participatory Budgeting and Local Development: Impacts, Challenges, and Prospects.” Local Development & Society 5(3):433–45.
Shair-Rosenfield, Sarah. 2025. “Decentralisation, Intergovernmental Coordination, and Response to Extreme Events in Southeast Asia.” Regional Studies 59(1):3–6.
Siboni, Benedetta, Paola Canestrini, and Giovanna Galizzi. 2025. “New Development: Gender-Responsive Budgeting beyond Institutionalization—Challenges from the Health Sector.” Public Money & Management 1(1):1–5.
Singh, Dawinder. 2025. “The Ethics of Law: Understanding Legal Norms Through the Lens of Humanistic Thought.” International Journal of Humanities & Legal Research 1(1):37–59.
Smith, Dale. 2023. “Dworkin, Ronald: On Justice.” Pp. 818–23 in Encyclopedia of the Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands.
Smith, Jackie and Michael Goodhart. 2024. “Human Rights Globalization: How Local and Global Actions Institutionalize Human Rights.” Journal of Human Rights 23(2):125–33.
Snidal, Duncan. 2025. “How Informal Intergovernmental Organizations Facilitate Cooptation and Promote Peaceful Change in Times of Power Rivalry.” Contemporary Security Policy 46(1):150–76.
Sugirman, Andi, Jumriani Nawawi, Irfan Amir, and Dinesha Samararatne. 2025. “Integration of Constitutional Law and Human Rights: A Comparative Study between Indonesia and South Africa.” Jurnal Suara Hukum 7(1).
Szoszkiewicz, Łukasz. 2024. “Business and Human Rights in Central and Eastern Europe: Constitutional Law as a Driver for the International Human Rights Law.” Business and Human Rights Journal 9(1):15–31.
Tuzet, Giovanni. 2025. “Legal Systems and Complexity: A Comment on Allen.” Ratio Juris 38(2):94–107.
Wahab, Abdul. 2025. “Public Policy Formulation with Justice: Administrative Law Perspective.” International Journal of Scientific Research 2(1):17–25.
Wahyudianto, Idris, Agus Sholahuddin, and Roos Widjajani. 2025. “Policy Implementation Analysis of Restrictions on Participatory Planning Proposals in Development Planning Consultation.” International Journal of Research in Social Science and Humanities 06(01):175–86.
Westerstrand, Salla. 2025. “Towards Just Democracies in the Age of Pervasive Digital Systems—a Rawlsian Approach.” AI & Society 3–5.
Widodo, Hananto, Dicky Eko Prasetio, Ridwan Arma Subagyo, and Sunanta Chemaming. 2024. “Legal Implications of the Authority of Acting Regional Heads Based on Policy Regulations.” Indonesian Journal of Administrative Law and Local Government 1(1):65–81.
Widowati and Vu Le Giang. 2025. “Child Punishment Versus the Principle of Non-Discrimination in the Perspective of Human Rights: A Legal Comparison Between Indonesia and Vietnam.” Jurnal Suara Hukum 7(1):245–73.
Xia, Hanlin and Lin Zhang. 2025. “The Coordination of Monetary and Local Government Fiscal Policies and Local Fiscal Sustainability in China.” Sustainability 17(16):7555.
Zhao, Qing and Chih-Hung Yuan. 2025. “Research on the Dual Effects of Environmental Protection Tax Law on Green Transformation of China’s Industry.” Frontiers in Environmental Science 13(1):1–5,
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Yanti Aneta, Asna Aneta, Rustam Tohopi, Pebriyanto A. Hulinggi, Princess Alyssa D. Tee-Anastacio
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Abstract views: 283
,
PDF Downloads: 311
